Roofing, Siding, Gutters, Windows and Fencing

When it comes to roofing materials, homeowners have a variety of options to choose from. Two popular choices are polycarbonate roofing and metal roofing. Both roofing options have advantages and disadvantages, and it can take time to determine which is best for your home. 

This guide answers questions about polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing to help you make an informed decision. From affordability to durability, maintenance to energy efficiency, we’ll cover everything you need to know about these roofing materials.

Polycarbonate roofing

Polycarbonate roofing is a lightweight and durable material made from thermoplastic. It is commonly used in roofing due to its high impact resistance and good insulation properties. Polycarbonate is widely used in building and construction, particularly in roofing. Polycarbonate roofing also provides UV protection, which can help protect the interior of your home from sun damage.

One of the main advantages of polycarbonate roofing is its lightweight nature, which makes it easier to install and can help reduce the installation cost. It is also relatively easy to cut and shape, allowing greater design flexibility. Additionally, polycarbonate roofing is a good choice for areas prone to hailstorms or other weather events, as it is less likely to crack or shatter than other materials.

However, there are some disadvantages to polycarbonate roofing. While it is impact-resistant, it is not as durable as metal roofing and can be prone to scratches and dents. Over time, it may get discolored or cloudy due to exposure to weather conditions.

Metal roofing

metal roof

Metal roofing vs. polycarbonate roofing is a popular debate among homeowners because metal is known for its durability and longevity, resisting fire, wind, and insects while low maintenance. 

It can last several decades with minimal maintenance making it a good investment and can increase a home’s energy efficiency by reflecting heat and reducing cooling costs. However, it comes with higher costs and is more challenging to install due to its weight, requiring specialized tools and equipment, which can add to the overall installation cost. 

Polycarbonate roofing, on the other hand, is usually more affordable but may not be as durable or long-lasting as metal roofing.

Polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing: Cost

One of the main factors homeowners consider when comparing metal vs. polycarbonate roofing is cost. Polycarbonate roofing is generally less expensive than metal roofing, making it a popular choice for homeowners on a budget. The cost of polycarbonate roofing varies depending on the thickness and quality of the material, but it is generally more affordable than metal roofing.

On the other hand, metal roofing is more expensive than polycarbonate roofing due to its durability and longevity. The cost of metal roofing also varies depending on the type of metal used, but it is generally more expensive than polycarbonate roofing.

Polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing: Durability

Metal roofing provides higher durability and a longer life span, with minimal maintenance required to maintain its longevity, estimated to be up to several decades, while polycarbonate roofs typically only last 10-15 years. 

Polycarbonate is more prone to scratches and dents over time, compromising its durability compared to the resistance of metal roofing against weather elements. In terms of investment and long-term guarantee in quality, metal stands out as the superior option when choosing metal vs. polycarbonate roofing.

Polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing: Maintenance

When it comes to metal roofing vs. polycarbonate roofing maintenance, both are relatively low-maintenance choices but have differences in upkeep. 

Metal roofing requires less maintenance and can last for years with minimal cleaning. In contrast, polycarbonate roofing may require more frequent cleaning and check-ups to prevent discoloration and cloudiness due to exposure to the elements. 

While polycarbonate roofing allows natural light into your home, regular cleaning is key to maintaining its clear look; however, this extra effort may be worthwhile as it is much more lightweight than metal roofing. When choosing polycarbonate vs. metal roofing, it is crucial to consider the upkeep required for either choice.

Polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing: Energy efficiency

Metal roofing reflects heat, helping keep the home cooler in hot weather and reducing cooling costs, making it a popular choice for homeowners in warm climates. 

On the other hand, polycarbonate roofing can provide insulation benefits for those with extreme temperatures but is less effective at reducing cooling costs compared to metal roofing. Choosing polycarbonate vs. metal roofing may depend on the location or the property’s use.


Which is better for storm damage, polycarbonate or metal roofing?

Both polycarbonate and metal roofing are durable and can withstand storm damage. However, metal roofing is generally considered more durable and long-lasting, making it a better option for areas with frequent severe weather. Polycarbonate roofing can be more prone to cracking and chipping, but it is still a good option for areas with milder weather conditions. And in case of damage, you can get storm damage roof repair services to restore your roofing. 

Is polycarbonate roofing a good choice for areas prone to hurricanes or other extreme weather events?

While polycarbonate roofing is impact-resistant, metal roofing in extreme weather conditions may be less durable. Metal roofing is generally better for areas prone to hurricanes or other severe weather events.

Can polycarbonate roofing be recycled?

Yes, polycarbonate roofing can be recycled, which makes it an environmentally friendly option.

Is metal roofing more prone to rust than other roofing materials?

The risk of rust depends on the type of metal used for the roofing material. Galvanized steel, for example, is less prone to rust than other types of metal. Additionally, metal roofing is typically coated with a protective layer to prevent rust and corrosion.

Does polycarbonate roofing require special maintenance?

Polycarbonate roofing requires regular cleaning to prevent discoloration or cloudiness, but it does not require any special maintenance beyond that.

Can polycarbonate roofing be used for flat roofs?

Yes, polycarbonate roofing can be used for flat roofs, but it is important to ensure the material is installed properly to prevent leaks.

Does metal roofing require additional insulation?

While metal roofing can provide some insulation benefits, it may require additional insulation depending on the climate and location of the home.

Which roofing material is more customizable?

Polycarbonate roofing is more customizable than metal roofing, as it is easier to cut and shape, allowing for greater design flexibility and creative options.

Final thoughts

In conclusion, homeowners have several factors to consider when comparing polycarbonate roofing vs. metal roofing. While polycarbonate roofing is a good choice for those on a budget, metal roofing is a better long-term investment due to its durability and longevity. 

Both materials have unique advantages and disadvantages; the choice ultimately depends on your needs and preferences. In case of possible storm damage, choosing a roofing material that can withstand harsh weather conditions and provide adequate protection for your home is important. 

Whether you opt for lightweight and impact-resistant polycarbonate roofing or durable and energy-efficient metal roofing, both options offer reliable protection and aesthetic appeal for your home. If you have any questions, SCR roofers in Terrell can help you navigate your roofing options.



SCR, Inc is hiring for a Sales Rep position. Please send your resume to in**@sc****.com or click the button to fill out an online application.